As you can see, they’re not dupes. Although the scattered holo effect is comparable, shade and application are different. Shaka’s holos are thin and need sandwiching, while Astra’s are easier to apply without having to be extra careful.
Shaka is € 1,99/5ml, and Astra is € 4,00/12ml.
Holo is my favourite finish for the summer (duochromes for winter), so I’m happy to own them all. If you’d rather have only some of them, I hope this can work as a reference for you.
Hve you tried any of these? Which is your favourite?